Doctor Who - The Doctor's Daughter

- Comments (1)

The Doctor's Daughter takes what could have been a cringey idea and actually does a pretty good job, making it one of the most enjoyable episodes of the series.

"Hello, Dad!"

Spoilers Ahead

Okay, bad stuff first: 

  • Instant clones, I'll let off.
  • Terraforming glowing gas, could have done better.
  • "I'm Doctor Martha Jones, who the hell are you?" Groan.
  • "Make the foundation of this society, a man who never would." Groan again.

Otherwise it was an entertaining story. The Doctor's daughter, Jenny, being a clone was a nice way into the moral issues. Jenny is a soldier, and she sees The Doctor as a soldier, but The Doctor doesn't see himself as a soldier despite fighting in an epic war. Jenny was an entertaining character, actually coaxing emotion out of the Doctor, for the first time in what feels like ages. More Time-war stuff please! I also enjoyed how the relationship between Jenny and The Doctor changed slowly, from disdain to acceptance in a quite believable way.

Meanwhile, as Jenny was winning me over, Martha was enhancing my opinion that's she's a waste of space. I don't like the character, or the acting, it all feels so false. Compare her to Donna/Tate, who is a much more fun character, and much more real in emotional situations.

The battle between the humans and the Hath was mere backdrop, although I liked the twist about the war lasting only a week, and the expendability of the clones. That's a pretty cool proper SF idea.

I thought Jenny would probably die at the end, I didn't think they'd bother to bring her back again. I suppose they can't resist setting up another spin-off series (unless she comes back later in the series, which I doubt). Pseudo-regeneration? And wasn't that Blakes 7 music at the end, when Jenny was leaving the planet?!

Nice job, Stephen Greenhorn.

Categories :


1 Comments

Huw said:

Thinking about groan moments, why was Jenny wearing mascara? A bigger problem though is that if each generation is taking place in a day or less where did the old man come from? Do they clone old soldiers?

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by James published on May 12, 2008 12:51 PM.

Eric Brown reviews Reynolds, Scalzi, Whates and Smith in The Guardian was the previous entry in this blog.

Steven Moffat Wins BAFTA For Blink is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Possibly of Interest